An American hero says it is time to leave Afghanistan

Matthew Hoh is not yet a household name. He should be.

Hoh is an American patriot. He is a former Marine captain who, NPR reports, was cited for uncommon bravery during a tour in Iraq. He led reconstruction efforts in Saddam Hussein’s home town of Tikrit as a civilian Defense Department employee. And, as a foreign service officer in Afghanistan, he worked on development efforts in Zabul province, considered a Taliban hotbed.

But this week Hoh made headlines for a different reason when it surfaced that he had become the first U.S. official to publicly resign his post over the war in Afghanistan.  He then declined a job on the senior embassy staff, The Washington Post reports, and another job, working in Washington, D.C., for Richard C. Holbrooke, the administration’s special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Hoh’s action has led him, among other things, to a lengthy interview on NPR’s “All Things Considered” and a forum on the pages of  His decision also has prompted considerable chatter on the blogosphere.

So why did Matthew Hoh resign? It is not, he emphasizes in his NPR interview with Melissa Block, over how United States should wage its war in Afghanistan. He does not believe we should be there. Period.

“Why are we losing soldiers and Marines in combat to people who are fighting us really only because we are occupying them?” he asks Block, adding later, “Is it worth losing more lives? Is it worth spending billions of dollars that frankly this country does not have?”

Hoh, as he told The Washington Post, is not some “peacenik.” He simply believes al-Qaeda has long ago abandoned a strategy of keeping a safe haven in a single country, yet the United States keeps fighting the Afghan War under outdated premises. He further believes, that the Afghans, who throughout history have fiercely rebuffed invader after invader, simply want to be left alone and that our presence exacerbates problems of the region.

In his  four-page resignation letter, submitted Sept. 10, 2009, he put it this way:  “I have lost understanding of and confidence in the strategic purposes of the United States’ presence in Afghanistan. I have doubts and reservations about our current strategy and planned future strategy, but my resignation is based not upon how we are pursuing this war, but why and to what end.”

As the White House leaked presumably well-orchestrated news in The New York Times this weekend that the Obama Administration is finalizing plans to stay the course in Afghanistan by trying to stabilize major population centers, Hoh’s words are particularly sobering.  He notes that American troops have been in Afghanistan for eight years now, just one short of a Soviet occupation that ended in failure. “Like the Soviets,” he notes, “we continue to serve and bolster a failing state, while encouraging an ideology and system of government unknown and unwanted by its people.”And he draws another parallel: America’s involvement in Vietnam.

So will anybody listen?  It seems unlikely,  given that the reported views of Vice-President Joe Biden and the advice of influential moderate columnist Thomas Friedman and influential conservative columnist George Will have yet to stop the march toward more troops and more involvement. This, as the body count rises and our national debt grows.

Sitting in my office, reading reports filtering from Afghanistan, reading Hoh’s letter, I feel something like a helpless passenger in a car hurtling toward a wreck in slow motion.  If Barack Obama tethers himself further to the Bush Administration’s failed policies in Afghanistan, I believe his own presidency can only end in failure, too.  That may please Republicans. But no Americans will benefit.

Writes Hoh: “We are mortgaging our Nation’s economy on a war, which, even with increased commitment, will remain a draw for years to come.”


About jerrylanson

I teach, write, coach and sing, though you're not required to listen to the latter. I'm a journalism professor at Emerson College in Boston. My third book, "Writing for Others, Writing for Ourselves," was published in November by Rowman & Littlefield Publishing. You can read a sample chapter at My passions are politics (generally liberal in outlook), music, mountains, golden retrievers and my grandchildren, though not in that order. Please stop by and mix it up with me. I always answer those who post.
This entry was posted in Afghanistan, American wars, Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to An American hero says it is time to leave Afghanistan

  1. lilbirdblue says:

    With all the crazy going on… bailouts, health care/public option, CEO bonuses, etc. THIS is the think that irks me the most! I really want us out of there, this is crazy. I feel so bad for people having to go and being taken away from their families, for what?!?!? I just don’t understand why.

    “Why are we losing soldiers and Marines in combat to people who are fighting us really only because we are occupying them?”

    • Jerry Lanson says:

      I’m with you. Sadly it seems once we get into wars we have a hard time remembering why we did and why we’re still there. One of the things Hoh talked about in his NPR interview is the fact that Afghanistan really is a series of tribal valleys rather than a united country. Given that the president’s brother now is reportedly both a drug kingpin and a CIA operative I just don’t believe we’re going to win any hearts and minds by patrolling the countryside.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s